As the debate over health care rages in the halls of Congress there was a local incident that brings the issue into perspective.
A few weeks ago Mercer County Common Pleas Judge Christopher St. John was faced with sentencing James G. Hogg. The Jefferson Township man had been charged with burglary and he pleaded guilty to receiving stolen property.
In open court St. John told Hogg he probably deserved a long sentence for stealing from two homes. But it turns out that he has extensive medical problems including stage 2 lyme disease, a bacterial infection that can cause fever, fatigue and other symptoms.
St. John was faced with two ugly choices: have Hogg hauled off to jail which would put the county on the hook for some very expensive medical treatment, or impose and suspend a state prison sentence and place Hogg on 4 years’ probation with fingers crossed in hope that he won’t commit another crime during the period.
Weighing the scales of justice St. John opted for the latter. His reasoning should give everyone pause. If he had sentenced Hogg to serve his time in county jail, the county, in effect, would have been subjected to cruel and unusual punishment in the form of high-cost medical care for a convicted criminal.
This says a lot about our society. Due to a lack of a national health plan we are now sentencing criminals based on the cost of their medical care.
Jails were created to punish criminals, not reward them. But that’s exactly what’s happening to those with severe medical conditions who commit crimes and get caught. Criminals could actually find themselves financially better off behind bars because a county or city would have to fork out the money to pay for their treatment.
Just one prisoner could have a medical condition so dire and expensive to treat that it could force a county into financial ruin.
We are aware that many of the crooks sentenced to prison are probably getting medical care on the public dole anyway through Medicaid or local funding sources. At least with a national health insurance plan the risk is spread out and and those without access to private health plans would have other options.
It would also afford our judges the option to dispense justice without having to conduct a medical cost analysis.
Opinion
OUR VIEW: Medical costs shouldn't lead to get out of jail free card
- Opinion
-
-
Juicy tips will be far fewer without ‘Scoop’ on the phone
I enjoyed calling him Scoop. I was the newspaper guy, but for more years than I can remember, Gary Douglas was at the other end of phone calls on a regular basis.
“Did you hear about this? Did you hear about that? Did you hear about so-and-so? Better check this out. I’ll bet you haven’t heard about this.”
That usually was the flow of the conversation. Most of the time he was right. Some of the tips turned into stories that were fit to print, and others not so much.
-
The only thing we have to fear is fear-mongering
To hear some folks tell it, it’s no longer morning in America, it’s five minutes to midnight. They say the United States, once the greatest nation on Earth, is today on a glide path to the ash heap of history.
-
Super Bowl Sunday brings a super boost for the local economy
The game is more than a glitzy international event. It serves as a one-day boon to local economies like ours here at home.
-
Punxsutawney Phil, Mitt and a litany of bad GOP hopefuls
Here are some thoughts from a guy who doesn’t put a whole lot of stock in rascally rodents that make weather forecasts.
-
In Ed Likovich’s yard, apples don’t fall very far from the tree
Adage tells us that the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree. It really applies to the Likovich family of Hermitage, specifically Ed the father and teacher and Ed the son and student.
-
A smaller state legislature? Don’t hold your breath
Don't tell me that our state General Assembly is finally going to do what should have been done many years ago – cut the size of the Legislature.
-
A sad end to life: History will determine JoePa’s legacy
I had the privilege, yes privilege and honor, of meeting Joe Paterno several times in my life, both as a student at Penn State and in my role as editor of The Herald. It was with a heavy heart when I learned that he was near death during the Mercer County Hall of Fame’s annual dinner at the Park Inn by Radisson Saturday, and that he had died Sunday.
-
OUR VIEW: Dearth of candidate interest defies worth of legislative races
In case you hadn’t noticed, this is an election year. Actually every year is, but this is one of the big ones. Sure, there’s some sort of presidential race going on, but that’s just a sideshow to where the real action in this year’s election is – or at least should be.
Voters across the country will be electing every member of the U.S. House of Representatives, and here in Mercer County voters will help decide who represents three state House districts. -
Hall of Fame weekend stirs memories of ‘good old days’
Is there anything better than reminiscing about the “good old days”? That’s why I love the Mercer County Hall of Fame’s annual induction weekend.
-
We couldn’t fool anyone - the neighborhood always snitched
An old African proverb tells us that it takes a village to raise a child. At least two books drawing lessons from the proverb have been written, including the most famous in 1996 by Hilary Clinton, “It Takes A Village: And Other Lessons Children Teach Us.”
- More Opinion Headlines
-
