Local News
UPDATE: Quaker Steak met obligations to franchisee, judge rules
SHARON — A bankruptcy judge has ruled in favor of Quaker Steak & Lube of Sharon and several of its officials in a lawsuit filed by a former franchisee, whose restaurant went out of business last year.
As part of its bankruptcy case, Bono Holdings Inc. and Salone Holdings Inc. of DuBois filed the suit against two Lube companies — Quaker Steak & Lube Franchising Corp. and Lube Holdings Inc. — and six company officials, including founders Gary J. Meszaros and George S. “Jiggs” Warren.
While U.S. Bankruptcy Court Judge Bernard Markovitz, Pittsburgh, is far from a flowery writer, his 28-page opinion gives the Bono/Salone case a good drubbing.
Voicemail messages left after hours Tuesday with Meszaros and Warren were not immediately returned.
“We are extremely disappointed by the court’s decision,” said William K. Labovitz of Lynch Weis, Cranberry Township, attorney for Bono and Salone. “We continue to believe that Quaker Steak & Lube behaved improperly with respect to our clients but, obviously, the judge disagreed with us.”
Labovitz added that a more thorough review of the opinion is required before an appeal decision can be made.
Bono, owned by Larry Salone, opened the Patton Township Lube near State College on Jan. 18, 2006, about six months after Bono and Lube officials signed a franchise agreement.
The restaurant closed Nov. 26.
Salone said Lube officials lied to him about the restaurant’s prospects for profitability; approved too large a restaurant for the State College market; forced him to use a select list of food vendors and menu choices that hurt his chances for profitability; and did not provide adequate training, startup marketing or operational support.
At trial, Bono pressed claims of fraudulent and negligent misrepresentation, breach of contract and conspiracy to defraud and breach the contract.
In their pretrial statement, Lube officials said they told Salone they could not make statements about prospective sales or earnings, and recommended that he speak to other franchisees.
The defendants said Salone never complained they had breached the contract until the suit was filed, and that they lived up to their end of the deal.
The trial was held May 18-20 before Markovitz.
In his opinion filed Tuesday, Markovitz said Bono claimed Lube officials had told him the restaurant would bring in gross revenues of $100,000 a week.
Actual revenues were $80,000 a week in 2006, $61,000 a week in 2007 and $45,000 a week in 2008.
Projections given to Salone concerning revenues were just that, not a representation of historical fact, Markovitz said, who added that he doubted that someone with as much business experience as Salone has would construe the figures as historical fact.
As a projection, the figures were neither true nor false when Salone received them, the judge said.
He added that the figures were given to Salone when he sought to buy stock, not a franchise, calling his reliance on them when considering to buy the franchise “not justifiable.”
Salone also had an accountant prepare an independent sales projection and, in the franchise agreement, said that he did not rely on sales projection figures other than those presented in the agreement, Markovitz said.
In the breach of contract charge, Bono alleged Quaker Steak did not provide sufficient site-selection assistance, training or start-up marketing, not that it did not provide any assistance, Markovitz said.
Quaker Steak officials “made bona fide attempts to fulfill its obligations which arose under the franchise agreement,” Markovitz said.
“It was not until well after the restaurant ‘went south’ and was closed that plaintiffs found fault with defendants’ performance and accused them of not acting in good faith,” the judge said.
A civil conspiracy charge depends on proof that the underlying offense was committed, he said. In this case, fraudulent and negligent misrepresentation and breach of contract were not proven, so there was no conspiracy, he said.
The plaintiffs barely mentioned conspiracy in their pretrial brief, and ignored it in their post-trial brief, Markovitz said.
“This suggests that Count IV (conspiracy) was little more than an afterthought and that plaintiffs were not serious about it.” he said.
The plaintiffs were seeking more than $5 million in lost investments and profits.
- Local News
-
-
Pedophile going to prison 10-20 years for 2nd offense
The Harrisville man who pleaded guilty to the repeated sexual assault of an 8-year-old girl over a 3è-year period told the judge he couldn’t help himself when he was sentenced to 10 to 20 years in prison Friday.
Jason L. Hites, 28, said he tried to stop himself, “but part of me kept pushing me and pushing me to do the things.” -
Killer to serve 27 to 54 years
It was January when Calvin Young Jr. flew into a rage and shot the mother of his child to death in front of his 2-year-old daughter. Friday, he pleaded guilty. -
Road plans take shape
Although bridge s dominate PennDOT’s construction plans for the next four years, there are significant road projects coming up.
Most notably, PennDOT plans to begin work next year on the long-awaited paving and widening of Broadway Avenue in Wheatland, Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard in Farrell and South Dock Street in Sharon, according to the Transportation Improvement Project approved Wednesday. -
Local Red Cross linking up with Butler chapter
The local chapter of the American Red Cross has a new partner.
Under a reorganization that became effective July 1, the Mercer County chapter was moved out of the Youngstown Red Cross to the Butler County Red Cross. -
Truck Night duty keeps police busy
The calls Brookfield police detective Peter Gibb gets on Friday nights as he works security at Yankee Lake Truck Night range from the serious to the mundane.
On a recent Friday, Gibb has to: help get a 13-year -old who hit his head on a truck’s roll cage to the paramedics, bring a wrist band that indicates drinking age to a man who didn’t get one at the door, shuttle the fire chief to inspect fireworks, and remind a family that intends to tailgate before entering the grounds that they can’t.
“It’s mostly drama,” Gibb said.
-
Flat rate wins out, but it’s going up
Hermitage officials plan to use the same rate structure when they raise residential sanitary sewer user fees in January, although the billing cycle will change from quarterly to monthly in 2012.
Officials considered a volumetric rate — combining a flat-rate charge and a consumption charge — but favored the flat-rate structure already in place, which stays in line with a consultant’s advice. -
Dahlkemper-Kelly race is ‘toss-up,’ handicappers say
In spite of a rosy fundraising quarter, U.S. Rep. Kathy Dahlkemper has news to sweat about: Two Washington, D.C. political reports this week called her race against Mike Kelly a “toss-up.”
For Rothenberg and Cook political reports, that’s the most competitive ranking.
-
Marines-to-be get in fighting shape
Marine boot camp. It’s got a reputation almost as fierce as the warriors it produces, and that’s what brings together a half dozen recruits every week outside the Marine recruitment center in Park Place plaza, Hermitage.
Under the direction of Staff Sergeant Randy Jewett, the recruits run in formation through the nearby Hermitage school grounds and sweat through calisthenics, pull-ups and crunches to get in shape for some of the toughest training of their lives.
It’s called the delayed entry program, said Jewett, and it helps them to find recruits who might not be military-trim yet, but can get there in a few months to a year. -
District favoring sun power over wind for new school
Brookfield school officials are no longer considering installing a wind turbine to help power a new school building, but that doesn’t mean their interest in alternative energy has ended.
Brookfield Superintendent Tim Saxton said the district is looking into the possibility of installing solar panels on the K-12 school building being built for the 2011-2012 school year.
Saxton said they decided after some research that a wind power turbine wouldn’t be a good use of taxpayer money.
-
Turf work on track; could cost less than expected
An artificial surface manufacturer began installing the turf in Hornet Stadium Wednesday as the project proceeds on schedule.
The pace of donations for the project also is as Hermitage school officials had hoped, topping $100,000 toward a $150,000 goal.
Officials want the project to be completed in time for an Aug. 20 football scrimmage, although a contingency plan is in place if that doesn’t work out.
- More Local News Headlines
-
Pedophile going to prison 10-20 years for 2nd offense
