The Herald, Sharon, Pa.

Local News

December 13, 2008

Judge: Builder liable for $34,000 because of defects in home

By Joe Pinchot

HERMITAGE — A Mercer County judge has ruled that a home builder owes the Hermitage treasurer and tax collector and her husband more than $34,000 because of defects in their home.

Home builder Mill Creek Homes LLC, Boardman, Ohio, has asked Mercer County Common Pleas Judge Christopher J. St. John to reverse his decision or grant a new trial.

Bernie Telega Harry and her husband, Raymond W., signed a $212,921 contract with Mill Creek on Oct. 15, 1999, to buy their lot at 3857 Amhurst Drive and build a home on it.

The Harrys, represented by Stephen J. Mirizio, filed suit Feb. 20, 2002, alleging that Mill Creek failed to and/or neglected to finish the job. Among the Harrys’ complaints: Windows were defective or improperly installed, toilets were unlevel, drywall seams were unfinished, door locks and baseboards were improperly installed, and a sump pump was defective.

The Harrys said they paid First General Services of Pennsylvania $48,638 to fix the defects. They sued to try to recover First General’s cost plus court costs and interest.

Mill Creek responded that the Harrys refused to allow the company to complete or fix the home unless the builder performed tasks not required by the contract. Mill Creek argued that it had completed its obligations except for a few punch list items the Harrys did not let it perform.

Mill Creek sued American Architectural Products Inc., Wexford, which built and sold the windows.

St. John presided over several, nonconsecutive days of trial over the last three months and visited the home on Nov. 6. He rendered his verdict Nov. 18.

St. John said the contract required Mill Creek to buy and install Pella windows, but Mill Creek instead installed 27 American Weatherseal windows, which are less expensive.

The judge said he tried to operate each window and found it “patently obvious” they were defective, basing his ruling on his own observation and other testimony presented at trial.

Several cracks appeared in the drywall of the living room, foyer, dining room and loft that require patching, sealing and repainting, and four porch columns were substandard and rotted prematurely, he said.

St. John ruled that Mill Creek owes the Harrys $30,377 for window replacement and installation, $1,936 for drywall crack fixing and painting, $1,469 for column replacement and $450 to reimburse the Harrys for painting Mill Creek had agreed to pay for, but never did. The total is $34,232 plus court costs.

St. John ruled that Mill Creek breached its warranty and the warranty of habitability on those items, but did not grant the Harrys’ claim of negligent misrepresentation.

Mrs. Harry declined to comment on the verdict.

In a postverdict motion for reversal or a new trial, Mill Creek’s attorney, William G. McConnell Jr., said Mill Creek could only be found liable for the windows if the defect rendered the home uninhabitable.

McConnell said the judge’s visit to the house eight years later is insufficient proof that the windows are defective. Mill Creek argued that the Harrys needed to provide expert testimony, which they did not do.

He also said the Harrys would get a “windfall” if Mill Creek has to pay for Pella windows.

Text Only
Local News
  • Storm blows in fast, leaves damage

    A scattered storm that started in Michigan and pulled in moisture over Lake Erie organized itself into a locally-severe storm system Sunday over Mercer County.

    May 28, 2012

  • transit Transit is once-in-a-lifetime show

    A rare celestial wonder that won’t be seen again for more than a century is set to play out before our eyes and Farrell’s resident astronomer  is giving locals a chance to get a first-hand look at a “black dawn.”

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • Ominous clouds Storms rumble through parts of Mercer County

    Temperatures dropped nearly 20 degrees Sunday as storms rumbled through parts of Mercer County in the afternoon and again in the evening. Some areas experienced high gusting winds during the early storms. The later storms were less windy, but dumped a lot of rain in a short span in the Shenango Valley as well as outlying areas. Temperatures are forecast for in the 90s on Memorial Day, with a chance of storms in the afternoon. Check out Sunday's Herald both in print and here for more details.

     

     

    May 27, 2012 1 Photo

  • Board wants pay freeze


    Sharon City School District officials are asking staff to take a wage freeze for the second year in a row to help cover a $1.9 million gap in the 2012-2013 budget in the face of further funding cuts by the state.

    May 27, 2012

  • City taps Pa. grant for downtown facelift


    The colorful flower baskets hanging in downtown Sharon are just one of the planted seeds officials hope will help the once-bustling area grow.

    May 27, 2012

  • pension graphic Pension bomb ticking for city

    The city of Sharon pays more people who don’t work there anymore than folks who still do.

    And the amount of money the city must pay to the retirees is going up about $250,000 next year, a hike that creates more problems for the cash-strapped town, City Manager Scott Andrejchak said.

    May 26, 2012 1 Photo

  • Church softball league to Mormons: You’re out!

    The Grove City Area Church Softball League’s decision to exclude a Mormon team from Slippery Rock has sparked a controversy far beyond the local sandlot.

    May 26, 2012

  • Fired bus driver files lawsuit

    A Mercer County woman fired from her job as a school bus driver over a 25-year-old drug conviction filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against a state education official and Jamestown Area School District.

    May 26, 2012

  • Recycling program a bit too popular

    The  county’s effort at going green by encouraging recycling in rural areas has been a tremendous success by most accounts, but isn’t without a few glitches. In Wilmington Township, residents often only have a window of a few minutes to get cardboard recyclables in before the bin is full, prompting a discussion among Mercer County Commissioners Wednesday morning.

    May 25, 2012

  • District will tap reserve fund

    Reynolds school directors plan to fill a $374,567 hole in the 2012-2013 budget with money from the district’s fund balance.

    May 25, 2012